Enigma wrote:
Lat me start by saying what a great article!!
I wont go as far as the guy mentioned in (2) (in red above.
But my opinion of straight sticking is the following.
Its damn impressive --- and there is where it stops, its means nothing.
By using Enigma's calculations.
When straight sticking the only resistance you have is the weight set on your drag.
Force x 1 = force
Just for arguments sake.
It takes a fish to get tired 300m at your current drag setting (straight stick) so it means you have to retrieve 300m of line extra to land him.
Also it gives him 300m of line while you are retrieving him to "rest" again.
So if from the beginning you hold your rod at either 60, or 45 deg, you exert more pressure on him.
He should now tire at %???? quicker as there is more force also he will use %??? less line to tire
Bit of a catch 22 situation dont you think
Question --- what is the direct pressure you put onto 3.5 to 5.4mm of steel when straight sticking??
Because thats how thick the shafts on your reels spool are.
Also on your line (mono)
Mono can stretch in the region 10%. So with straight sticking there is no rod (bend) or arms to absorb any sudden bursts.
If the line is already stretched at 10% now meaning there is no stretch available to absorb any sudden movements, then its bye bye fish
with the rod bent you can absorb the sudden jerk either with the rod or your arms.
OK I have now opened the can of worms
Now for my actual reason for this post.
Some people have absolutely no idea of what 7kg and 17kg of drag is.
2. He locks his Saltiga lever drag at 17kg and within 1 hour with this locked drag exhausts and lands a 180kg Blacktip never once straight sticking as straight sticking is for Pussy's
So in answer to all this I took a pre-set Trinidad 50 from my box and put it on a 13' rod.
I let him try pull the line of the reel by hand to which he commented on how extremely tight the drag was but had to be carbontex.
I then fixed a scale to a harnas on the rod so he could measure the load bearing and see what the load was.
After towing him around for 5 minutes, getting him huffing and puffing and wringing his hands I packed it all away.
7.5kg drag setting preset and measured. 32kg load bearing, no comment other than the rod is a pole (Shark Extreme Heavy) and the drag is super smooth (Carbontex).
He had a look at the load bearing and I explained the load bearing principle and showed him that what he claimed -
15' (4.65m) rod with 650mm grip position with 17kg of drag would mean a load bearing of 100kg + for 1 hour solid??????
I don't want to arm wrestle this guy as at 1.75m and 70kg he must have Genetically enhance muscles.
Lat me start by saying what a great article!!
I wont go as far as the guy mentioned in (2) (in red above.
But my opinion of straight sticking is the following.
Its damn impressive --- and there is where it stops, its means nothing.
By using Enigma's calculations.
When straight sticking the only resistance you have is the weight set on your drag.
Force x 1 = force
Just for arguments sake.
It takes a fish to get tired 300m at your current drag setting (straight stick) so it means you have to retrieve 300m of line extra to land him.
Also it gives him 300m of line while you are retrieving him to "rest" again.
So if from the beginning you hold your rod at either 60, or 45 deg, you exert more pressure on him.
He should now tire at %???? quicker as there is more force also he will use %??? less line to tire
Bit of a catch 22 situation dont you think
Question --- what is the direct pressure you put onto 3.5 to 5.4mm of steel when straight sticking??
Because thats how thick the shafts on your reels spool are.
Also on your line (mono)
Mono can stretch in the region 10%. So with straight sticking there is no rod (bend) or arms to absorb any sudden bursts.
If the line is already stretched at 10% now meaning there is no stretch available to absorb any sudden movements, then its bye bye fish
with the rod bent you can absorb the sudden jerk either with the rod or your arms.
OK I have now opened the can of worms